Speaking as a woman (since I usually speak that way)...I would so be ok with that...almost. I am hard to buy for, since I usually just get what I want....so you can get my list so I already know everything and that is cool. But you gotta make some effort, even if it means going to the store with me to pick things outl.
Why don't you make up for it? Ask her what she wants and give it to her with a little naked dance??
